Flooring insight

The Karndean Flooring Batch That Taught Me to Ask 'What's Not Included'

2026-09-30 · Martin Kowalczyk

The Setup

In March 2024, I was standing in a Dallas warehouse with a clipboard and a very bad feeling. I’m a quality and brand compliance manager at a commercial flooring distributor. I review every product spec before it reaches customers—roughly 300 items a quarter. I’ve rejected 22%—maybe 24%, I’d have to check the Q1 report—of first deliveries in 2024 due to spec mismatches. That number sounds high until you see what shows up on pallets.

We were sourcing materials for a 120-room boutique hotel renovation. The spec called for Karndean flooring in the corridors and Karndean Honed Oyster Slate in the lobby. We also needed an LVP flooring supplier for back-of-house areas, a porcelain tile OEM for the bathrooms, and construction sealant for the expansion joints. That last one turned into a construction sealant OEM vs private label debate.

The project had a tight timeline. The owner wanted to open before the summer conference season. Every material had to be approved, ordered, and installed in six weeks. That’s not a lot of slack for a commercial job with three different flooring substrates.

The Quote That Looked Good on Paper

The private-label sealant quote was 18% cheaper than the OEM option. Similar specs on paper. The numbers said go private label. My gut said stick with the OEM. I went with my gut. Why? Traceability, batch testing, and because a $400 savings on sealant could turn into a $22,000 redo if it failed. Oh, and the OEM included ASTM C920 test reports.

Honestly, I wasn’t expecting much from the OEM’s sales rep. But they were actually pretty responsive. The private-label quote, meanwhile, didn’t include cure testing or freight. Once we added those, the OEM was basically 6% cheaper total. That was way more than I expected.

I’ve learned to ask ‘what’s NOT included’ before ‘what’s the price.’ The private-label quote looked lower because it left out things I’d have to pay for later. The OEM quote looked higher because it listed everything upfront. In the end, the transparent quote was the cheaper one. That’s not always true, but it’s true more often than not.

The Batch That Caught Me

The Karndean batch arrived on a Tuesday. I knew I should get written confirmation on the dye lot and bevel for the Honed Oyster Slate. But I thought, ‘We’ve used them for years. What are the odds?’ Well, the odds caught up with me.

The batch had a visible shade variation—more gray than the approved sample—and a 1.0 mm bevel against our 0.5 mm spec. Normal tolerance is ±0.2 mm. The vendor claimed it was ‘within industry standard.’ We checked it against ASTM F1700 and the manufacturer’s spec sheet. It wasn’t. We rejected 8,000 sq ft.

Had 2 hours to decide before the installers were scheduled. Normally I’d get multiple quotes or run a blind test, but there was no time. We went with rejection based on the spec sheet. The vendor redid the batch at their cost. It delayed the project by 10 days.

That delay hurt. The general contractor was not happy. The hotel owner was not happy. I spent two days on calls explaining why we couldn’t just ‘make it work.’ But making it work would have meant visible shade bands in the lobby and a bevel that didn’t match the transition strips. That’s the kind of thing guests notice—even if they can’t say why.

What I Do Now

That delay was painful. But if we’d installed the batch, the redo would have cost us $22,000 and pushed the opening. There’s something satisfying about catching a defect before it becomes a disaster. After all the stress, seeing the replacement batch match the sample—that’s the payoff.

For the porcelain tile OEM, we now require ANSI A137.1 test reports and a sample approval before production. For any LVP flooring supplier, we ask for a line-item breakdown: adhesive, transition strips, floor prep, freight, rush fees. The vendor who lists all fees upfront—even if the total looks higher—usually costs less in the end.

What I mean is that the ‘cheapest’ option isn’t just about the sticker price—it’s about the total cost including your time spent managing issues, the risk of delays, and the potential need for redos. Specs, samples, written confirmation. In that order. At least, that’s been my experience with commercial projects.

The best part of finally getting our vendor process systematized: no more 3am worry sessions about whether the order will arrive. That’s worth a ton of time and a lot of peace of mind.

Martin Kowalczyk
Martin Kowalczyk

Martin Kowalczyk is a sustainable-materials and construction-procurement analyst covering envelope products, structural materials, interior finishes, mechanical systems, prefabricated assemblies, and site infrastructure. He uses ISO 21930 construction-product rules and ISO 14025 environmental-declaration principles while comparing declared units, life-cycle modules, global-warming potential, recycled content, VOC evidence, reference service life, installed cost, and replacement cycles. His sourcing guides help architects, developers, and contractors compare technically equivalent options without confusing product performance, environmental disclosure, compliance evidence, and whole-life value.