Flooring insight

Why "We Can Do That Too" Is a Red Flag When Specifying Flooring

2026-08-27 · Emilia Novak

I review a lot of flooring specs. 200+ unique products a year, roughly—LVT, adhesives, underlayment, transitions, the whole ecosystem. And the phrase that makes me most uneasy isn't "cheap" or "expedited." It's "we can do that too."

That probably sounds backwards. Shouldn't you want a supplier who handles everything? Isn't that more efficient?

No. If you ask me, it's a red flag. The more categories a company claims to master, the less I trust their core one.

The Specialist Advantage

Karndean is a design flooring brand. They make LVT and LVP—luxury vinyl tile and plank—with an emphasis on realistic wood and stone visuals. That's basically it. They don't make ceramic tile, they don't make carpet, they're not going to pour your subfloor. What they do make is engineered very well, with three solid installation options: glue-down, loose lay, and Korlok click.

That focus is exactly why I spec them.

When a manufacturer's entire business depends on one product category, quality is existential. Their defect tolerance is tighter. Their R&D goes deeper. Their rejects get studied instead of buried. With a "full-range" supplier, flooring is one of ten departments competing for budget. With Karndean, it's the only department.

Karndean Click Flooring: The Tolerance Story

Here's a specific example. Karndean click flooring—Korlok—requires precise dimensional tolerances on the locking profiles. If the tolerances drift even slightly, you get gapping, squeaking, or joints that don't seat properly. When I receive a Korlok sample, I measure the plank widths and locking profiles against the published spec sheet. Over the years, those measurements have been remarkably consistent.

That consistency isn't accidental. It's the result of a company that has made click LVT a core competency, not a side experiment. I've seen click systems from generalist manufacturers where the profiles varied way more than they should between batches. I don't have hard data on industry-wide click tolerance drift, but based on my years of receiving and measuring samples, my sense is that specialist LVT manufacturers hold significantly tighter profiles—probably 2-3x tighter on average.

Tile Adhesive Specifications: Know Who the Expert Is

This is where the "expertise boundary" concept gets real.

I once worked on a project where the client wanted to use one supplier for everything—flooring, adhesive, underlayment. The supplier happily said "we can configure a full package for you." It sounded great. The tile adhesive specifications they provided turned out to be a generic product that wasn't suitable for the substrate. The job had to be torn up—or rather, fully removed and replaced, which took twice as long as the original install. That quality issue cost us a $22,000 redo and delayed the launch by six weeks.

Here's what I learned: the adhesive manufacturer is the expert on adhesive. Not the tile brand, not the flooring contractor, not the "full solutions provider."

The best adhesive manufacturers publish detailed data sheets, substrate preparation requirements, trowel notch recommendations, and open times. They have technical hotlines. They test their products against ASTM standards. That documentation—not a bundle quote—is what you should be specifying from.

"The vendor who said 'this isn't our strength—here's who does it better' earned my trust for everything else."

When a flooring supplier tells you to get adhesive specs from the adhesive manufacturer directly, that's not a limitation. It's professionalism.

Floor Underlayment OEM: Evaluate on Performance, Not Bundles

Underlayment is another category that seems simple but isn't. Depending on the application, you need different acoustic ratings, moisture vapor transmission rates, compressive strength, and flatness tolerance. If you're sourcing floor underlayment OEM, you should be evaluating manufacturers on those specific properties—not because they threw underlayment into a flooring bundle.

I made this mistake once. I assumed "same specifications" meant identical results across vendors. Didn't verify. Turned out the OEM underlayment we sourced from a bundled supplier was softer than the spec—too soft for our glue-down application. The installed floor developed subfloor telegraphing within months. Learned never to assume the proof is the product after receiving a batch that didn't match what we approved.

Now every contract I touch includes explicit underlayment performance requirements: thickness tolerance, density, compression set, acoustic performance. And those specs come from the underlayment manufacturer's data sheet, not from a generalist's sales brochure.

How to Evaluate Ceramic Tile Manufacturers

Since we're on the topic of boundaries, let's address ceramic tile directly. I get asked this constantly: "Can Karndean handle our tile project?" No—and they'll tell you that. But that doesn't mean you don't need tile. It means you need to evaluate ceramic tile manufacturers differently from how you'd evaluate an LVT manufacturer.

Here's what I look for:

  • Calibrated tolerances: Ceramic tile has published standards for dimensional variation, warpage, and surface quality. Ask for their internal QC data. A quality manufacturer tracks these metrics and can show you trends over time.
  • PEI rating transparency: The PEI rating tells you the tile's resistance to abrasion. A manufacturer who can clearly explain which PEI class suits which application—and which doesn't—shows real expertise boundaries.
  • Rectified vs. non-rectified: Understand what they're offering. Rectified tile is mechanically ground to precise dimensions. If they can articulate the difference and the installation implications, they know their product.
  • What they won't do: This is my #1 test. A ceramic tile manufacturer who admits "we can't help you with the LVT portion" is more trustworthy than one who claims to be a full solutions provider.

I ran a blind test with our design team a while back: same spec, two different ceramic tile manufacturers—one who specialized, one who diversified. 78% identified the specialist's tile as "more consistent" in dimensions without knowing the source. The cost difference was minimal. On a large commercial run, that consistency matters.

The "One-Stop-Shop" Appeal—and Why It's a Trap

Look, I get it. Fewer vendors, fewer invoices, maybe a volume discount. Part of me wants to consolidate too. Another part remembers the $22,000 redo.

The problem with one-stop shop is dilution. Every product category a supplier adds spreads their expertise thinner. Their best people are now solving ten technical challenges instead of one. Their QC resources are divided. Their attention—the most valuable resource in our industry—gets fragmented.

And when something fails, who takes responsibility? With one vendor, you get finger-pointing between their own departments. With a specialist, the accountability line is short. They made it. They own it. They fix it.

That's not to say ceramic tile is inferior to vinyl—it absolutely isn't. It's a different material with different strengths. The point is that a company's honesty about where their expertise ends is the strongest signal of how much you can trust it where it begins.

Bottom Line

I'd rather work with a specialist who knows their limits than a generalist who overpromises. Every time.

Karndean isn't going to spec your tile adhesive—and that's how it should be, because the adhesive manufacturer is the expert there. Your floor underlayment OEM should be judged on underlayment performance, not on bundle discounts. And your ceramic tile manufacturer should be evaluated by calibrated tolerances and transparent data, not by their claims to be a "complete flooring source."

The next time a supplier says "we can do that too," ask them how many of that specific thing they've actually done. Ask for their defect data. Ask for their specialist's phone number.

If they can't give you a straight answer, that's your answer.

Emilia Novak
Emilia Novak

Emilia Novak is a flooring and architectural-surfaces analyst covering ceramic and porcelain tile, natural stone, resilient flooring, underlayments, countertops, adhesives, grout, and installation accessories. She uses ASTM C373 and ASTM C648 test evidence while comparing water absorption, breaking strength, slab flatness, substrate moisture, joint width, slip resistance, and installed tolerances. Her specification guides help architects, contractors, and buyers match surface systems to traffic, wet-area exposure, maintenance demands, and substrate conditions.